Will WTI oil on Nov 10, 2026 close above $85.99?
6 seats worked this question alone; the panel agreed within a few points, so no debate was run. Code ran every test and computed the number. How the desk works
Judged by Kalshi KXWTI-26NOV1014-T85.99 settlement at 2026-11-10: If the daily settlement price for WTI crude oil(December 2026 contract) on November 10, 2026 is above 85.99 USD/Bbl, then the market resolves to Yes.
The dispute that matteredThe six analysts agree the question is a volatility-tail problem (spot 91.24 vs strike 85.99, needing a ~5.8-5.9% one-day decline), but they disagree on how fat the left tail is: B (0.94) and E (0.95) use shorter/calmer windows (sd≈3.2-3.9%, n=68-122) that push the required move to ~1.6-1.8 sd, implying only 3-6% breach probability; A (0.89), D (0.88) and F (0.93 but closer to the fat-tail camp) use longer windows (n=171-274) that explicitly include the realized 8.66% one-day drop on 11/04, pulling the empirical 5th percentile out to -6% to -7.6% and raising breach probability to 10-11%. I resolved this by weighting toward the longer-sample, fat-tail estimates: the 11/04 drop is an observed data point in the same regime (not a hypothetical), so excluding it (as the shorter-window analysts implicitly do) understates tail risk. This pulls my consensus below the naive top-end (0.95) but above the pooled algorithm's 0.92, landing at 0.91.
Synthesis
- WTI (Dec26 contract) closed at $91.24 on 2026-11-09, which is 5.75-5.76% above the $85.99 Kalshi strike.
- A one-day drop of 8.3-8.66% occurred on 2026-11-04, within the lookback window used by all analysts.
- Daily log-return sd estimates range 3.21%-4.03% depending on sample window (n=68 to n=274) and ending date.
- All six analysts' calibration track records in this segment show accuracy between 52.3% and 57.4% against confident (0.88-0.95) stated probabilities, with Brier scores clustered 0.265-0.275 -- near coin-flip informativeness despite high confidence.
- Empirical/bootstrap 1-day log-return distributions (percentile interpolation by A, B, C, E, F; 20,000-resample Monte Carlo by D) used to convert the -5.92% breach threshold into a tail probability.
- Calibration-weighted log-odds pooling of the six post-debate probabilities producing the deterministic 0.92 pool estimate.
- The required -5.92% log-return to breach the strike sits between the 5th and 11th percentile of the empirical 1-day return distribution, depending on which sample window is used.
- The committee's apparent 'agreement' (0.88-0.95 range) is largely six analysts re-deriving tail probabilities from overlapping or identical WTI return series, not six independent information sources -- effective independent evidence count is closer to 2-3 (spot-vs-strike gap; return-distribution tail estimate via two distinct methods: percentile lookup vs. Monte Carlo bootstrap).
- No Kalshi order-book or market-implied probability was observed by any analyst, so there is no direct evidence this view diverges from what the market already prices.
- WTI Dec26 settles above $85.99 on 2026-11-10 with probability ~0.91 (90% CI 0.85-0.96), i.e., resolution is YES with high but not extreme confidence.
- The 1-in-10 to 1-in-20 scenario (a >5.8% one-day decline) remains the dominant source of NO-outcome risk; absent such a shock, YES resolves.
- Whether the 11/04 8.66% drop should be treated as in-regime evidence of a fat tail (lowering P(YES)) or as an idiosyncratic outlier that should be downweighted (raising P(YES)) -- this single choice drives most of the 0.88-0.95 spread across analysts.
- Whether any current overnight news, inventory data, or geopolitical catalyst exists between 2026-11-09 close and settlement that could independently drive a large move -- none of the six analysts report checking for this, so the estimate is purely statistical/distributional, not fundamentals-informed.
- The true market-implied probability (Kalshi order book) is unobserved, so it is uncertain whether 0.91 represents an actual trading edge or simply agrees with consensus pricing.
| Commodities Analyst (A) | 0.19 | Highest domain relevance (1.0 commodities) and explicitly incorporates the 11/04 8.66% drop into the tail estimate rather than treating it as noise; largest sample use (n=171) gives reasonable data quality. Down-weighted slightly because its return-distribution evidence overlaps heavily with B/C/D/E/F (same underlying WTI return series, different windows). |
| Weather Analyst (B) | 0.08 | Low domain relevance to commodities pricing mechanics despite decent calibration; its bootstrap estimate (s3) is evidence of the same return series already captured by A/D, so largely duplicated. Kept nonzero because its specific bootstrap ES/5th-pct stat adds some independent statistical texture. |
| Public Markets Analyst (C) | 0.16 | Best raw calibration (accuracy 0.554, lowest Brier 0.265) and reasonable commodities relevance; evidence (d1, s2) duplicates the spot-gap and vol-sd stats used elsewhere, so treated as confirmatory rather than new, but calibration quality earns above-average weight. |
| Quantitative Researcher (D) | 0.18 | Runs an explicit Monte Carlo bootstrap (20,000 resamples) rather than relying only on point percentiles -- this is the most methodologically distinct (not just duplicated) piece of evidence, improving statistical quality; moderate domain relevance across the board (not commodities-specialized) caps the weight. |
| Positioning Analyst (E) | 0.12 | Uses a shorter, lower-sd window (n=122, sd=3.21%) that is somewhat inconsistent with the other analysts' wider/fatter-tailed estimates -- flags a real methodological disagreement (regime/window choice) rather than new independent data, and explicitly admits no order-book data, so downweighted for honesty about missing market-implied information. |
| Causal Skeptic (F) | 0.14 | Adds genuine value by correctly ruling out the wind-gust/COT 'causal' signals as irrelevant noise at this horizon (good epistemic hygiene), but its probability estimate still rests on the same core empirical-return-tail evidence as A/C/D, so weighted as moderately independent -- credited for the negative result (what doesn't matter) more than for new positive evidence. |
- If WTI (Dec26) settlement price on 2026-11-10 is below $85.99, this forecast is falsified (NO outcome against a predicted YES-leaning 0.91 probability).
- If realized committee calibration on this specific question (once resolved) shows a Brier score materially worse than the in-segment historical average of ~0.27, treat the panel's self-reported calibration weights as overstated for this regime going forward.
The seats
Commodities Analyst89%
92% Generic base rate for a 1-day binary oil settlement strike set ~6% below the prior close, assuming daily return vol near WTI's typical historical range (~2.0-2.5% sd): probability the market closes more than 1 sd below spot on a single day is low (~5-10%) under near-normal assumptions.
The 11/04 observation in d1 shows an -8.3% single-day drop (96.09 -> 88.12) just five trading days before this question's resolution date, meaning a move of similar magnitude has already occurred very recently and is well within the realized tail of d2's distribution (min=-17.9%). If whatever drove that shock (e.g., surprise inventory build, OPEC+ supply signal, demand scare) is still live or recurs, a repeat move of -6% from 91.24 is not a rare tail event but a demonstrated recent pattern, which would push the true probability of breaching 85.99 meaningfully above the ~10-11% implied by the unconditional empirical distribution."
- Last observed WTI close 2026-11-09 = 91.24, which is 5.75 USD (6.3%) above the 85.99 strike, giving meaningful cushion for a single trading day.
- Empirical 1-day log-return distribution (n=171, sd=4.03%, 5th pct=-7.47%, 25th pct=-1.94%) implies the required -5.92% move sits near the 10th-11th percentile of historical daily returns, i.e., roughly 10-11% probability of breaching the strike on any given day.
- Weekly vol proxy has been declining (8.8% -> 6.9% over the last ~6 weeks), suggesting some recent vol compression that modestly reduces tail risk relative to the full-sample d2 distribution.
If the Kalshi-settlement December WTI contract prints a daily settlement value <= 85.99 USD/Bbl on 2026-11-10 (observable via Kalshi settlement data or CME WTI Dec'26 futures close), this forecast is falsified."
- d1 series represents WTI front/December contract daily closes, with last observation 2026-11-09=91.24 being the most recent spot reference for the Nov 10 settlement.
- d2 is the daily log-return series for the same WTI contract (n=171, mean~0, sd=4.03%), used to estimate the one-day move distribution.
- The settlement threshold requires a one-day move of ln(85.99/91.24) = -5.92% from the 11/09 close.
- d3 (weekly, declining from 8.8% to 6.9%) is a realized/implied volatility proxy showing vol compression into early November, partially offsetting the fat left tail seen in d2.
- The wind-gust insight (insight:ins_01M3ZV4EM46811213JGQGR) is a 21-day-forward signal with a weak, small-magnitude beta and is not informative for a 1-day horizon.
debate skipped: panel unanimous within 0.07
Weather Analyst94%
Loading…
Public Markets Analyst90%
Loading…
Quantitative Researcher88%
Loading…
Market Positioning Analyst95%
Loading…
Causal Skeptic93%
Loading…
Claims and evidence
The debate
| Commod | Weathe | Public | Quanti | Market | Causal | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Commodities | ||||||
| Weather | ||||||
| Public Marke | ||||||
| Quantitative | ||||||
| Market Posit | ||||||
| Causal Skept |
WTI closed at 91.24 on 2026-11-09, which sits 6.3% above the 85.99 Kalshi strike. Using the empirical 1-day log-return distribution (d2, n=171, sd=4.03%, left-skewed with excess kurtosis), the required -5.92% log-return to breach the strike falls near the 10th-11th percentile of historical daily moves, implying roughly 10-11% probability of a NO outcome and ~89% probability of YES. This updates down modestly from a generic 92% base rate (for a strike ~6% OTM on a single day) because the recent realized-return tail in d2 is fatter than a naive calm-market assumption, and because d1 shows the contract just experienced an 8.3% one-day drop on 11/04, confirming the market is in an elevated-volatility regime, not a quiet one. The weekly vol proxy (d3) shows some compression into early November, which tempers but does not eliminate this risk. The wind-gust library insight is irrelevant at this 1-day horizon given its 21-day design and weak/negligible beta."
WTI (Dec26) settled 91.24 on 2026-11-09, which is 5.76% above the 85.99 strike. Based on the empirical daily-return distribution (sd≈3.9%, 5th percentile ≈ -5.99% to -6.0%), a one-day move sufficient to push settlement below 85.99 is a tail event (~roughly 1-in-17 to 1-in-20 trading days), so the contract most likely settles YES (above 85.99) on Nov 10.
WTI settled at $91.24 on 2026-11-09, roughly 5.75% above the $85.99 strike. Given one-day realized volatility (~4% daily log-return sd) and a fat-tailed/left-skewed return distribution, a single-day move large enough to push settlement below $85.99 (requires a ~5.93% log-return decline) is a tail event but not negligible given recent precedent of an 8.66% one-day drop on 2026-11-04. Net: price should settle YES (above $85.99) with high but not extreme probability.
Base rate from the full-sample empirical 1-day return distribution implies ~89% probability that WTI settlement remains above 85.99 given the current price of 91.24; this is primarily a volatility-tail question (needing a ~5.92% one-day log decline) rather than a directional trend question, and the recent realized volatility (including an 8.66% one-day drop five sessions ago) is already reflected in the sample used, keeping the estimate close to but not identical with the raw base rate.
WTI spot sits 5.75% above the 85.99 strike with one trading session to settlement; absent a large single-day shock exceeding ~1.8 sigma of recent realized volatility, the contract settles above the strike. The move needed to breach it is not unprecedented in the recent window (an 8.66% one-day drop occurred on 11/04), so tail risk is somewhat fatter than a clean normal model implies, trimming probability slightly below the naive base rate. No direct Kalshi order-book data was available, so the market-implied probability is proxied rather than observed, and any edge for a long-YES trade is likely thin if the market already prices this near-consensus view.
The question is effectively a random-walk threshold test: does WTI settle below 85.99 by tomorrow, a ~5.8% overnight drop from the last observed level (91.24). None of the supplied 'causal' signals (wind-gust momentum, COT positioning) have the strength, timing, or mechanism to move price 5-6% in one day, and several show signs of instability or spuriousness. The probability should be set almost entirely by the empirical distribution of 1-day returns, not by any causal story in the library.
debate skipped: panel unanimous within 0.07
debate skipped: panel unanimous within 0.07
debate skipped: panel unanimous within 0.07
debate skipped: panel unanimous within 0.07
debate skipped: panel unanimous within 0.07
debate skipped: panel unanimous within 0.07
Base rate for a ~6% OTM single-day threshold under a generic calm-market normal assumption would be roughly 95-97%; the empirical fat left-tail evidence (notably the 8.66% drop on 11/04, inside the lookback window for every analyst) updates this down to the 0.88-0.95 range the panel converges on. My consensus of 0.91 sits below the algorithmic log-odds pool of 0.92 because that pooling formally treats six analysts' outputs as independent evidence when in fact 4-5 of them are re-measuring the same WTI return series with different window lengths -- true independent evidence here is closer to two lines (the percentile-lookup approach and the Monte Carlo bootstrap approach), which should narrow, not widen, confidence versus naive pooling. Tradeability: this is NOT a clearly tradeable edge. No analyst observed the actual Kalshi market-implied price/order book, so there is no evidence the committee's 0.91 diverges from what the market already prices; absent that comparison, a YES position has unknown (likely thin-to-zero) edge, consistent with Analyst E's explicit caveat. If a desk wanted to express this view, the only defensible trade is a small YES position sized to the 0.85-0.96 CI only if the observed Kalshi ask is below ~0.85, with a stop/falsification at next-day settlement data -- otherwise stand aside given crowding of near-identical statistical reasoning (crowding=0.85) and low genuine novelty (0.15) in the evidence base.
Assumptions
- holdingd1 series represents WTI front/December contract daily closes, with last observation 2026-11-09=91.24 being the most recent spot reference for the Nov 10 settlement.
- holdingd2 is the daily log-return series for the same WTI contract (n=171, mean~0, sd=4.03%), used to estimate the one-day move distribution.
- holdingThe settlement threshold requires a one-day move of ln(85.99/91.24) = -5.92% from the 11/09 close.
- holdingd3 (weekly, declining from 8.8% to 6.9%) is a realized/implied volatility proxy showing vol compression into early November, partially offsetting the fat left tail seen in d2.
- holdingThe wind-gust insight (insight:ins_01M3ZV4EM46811213JGQGR) is a 21-day-forward signal with a weak, small-magnitude beta and is not informative for a 1-day horizon.
- holdingd2/d3 return series are representative of forward-looking volatility regime for the next single trading day
- holdingNo scheduled high-impact event (EIA report surprise, OPEC+ emergency decision, geopolitical shock) between 2026-11-09 and settlement that is not already reflected in the return distribution
- holdingDec2026 contract behaves consistent with the underlying WTI front/near-month series used to build d1-d4
- holdingSettlement mechanics do not introduce basis distortions versus the spot/futures series referenced
- holdingSettlement price for Nov 10 2026 December WTI contract tracks the front-month-adjacent return series represented in d1/d2 without a large basis/roll distortion.
- holdingNo major scheduled catalyst (EIA inventory release, OPEC+ meeting, geopolitical shock) between 2026-11-09 close and 2026-11-10 settlement that would materially shift the return distribution from recent history.
- holdingThe d2 return series is a reasonable proxy for WTI daily log returns and is stationary enough in volatility terms to apply to the next single day (d1 level series itself is non-stationary per s3, which is why returns were used instead).
- holdingd1 last value (91.24 on 2026-11-09) is the best available proxy for the price level feeding into the Nov 10 settlement.
- holdingDaily log-return distribution from d2/s5 (n=171, trailing ~8 months) is a reasonable proxy for the 1-day-ahead return distribution; regime hasn't structurally shifted overnight.
- holdingSettlement price ≈ last traded/closing price for the Dec2026 WTI contract, not materially different from the underlying spot series d1 tracks.
- holdingNo major scheduled macro/OPEC event between 03:30 UTC 11/09 snapshot and settlement that would cause a discontinuous jump not captured in historical return distribution.
- holdingWTI December 2026 futures settlement follows approximately a driftless log-normal one-day process consistent with recent realized daily log-return distribution (d2/s1).
- holdingd4 series represents open interest (contracts) and d5 represents daily volume; no explicit Kalshi order-book/implied-odds data was provided, so market-implied probability is inferred from distance-to-strike and historical vol, not directly observed.
- holdingNo major scheduled catalyst (OPEC meeting, EIA inventory shock) occurs between 2026-11-09 close and 2026-11-10 settlement beyond what's already reflected in the last 6 sessions of price action.
- holdingd1 is the same underlying series as the Kalshi settlement price (WTI Dec26 contract) or closely tracks it — UNVERIFIED, treated as working assumption only.
- holdingNo non-public information about Nov 10 inventory/OPEC data exists as of 2026-11-09 03:30 UTC cutoff.
- holdingDaily return distribution (s1) is stationary enough to apply to the next single day; this is an extrapolation, not a tested forward relationship for this specific transition.
Simulated trade
The portfolio manager proposed no paper trade. No analyst sourced the actual Kalshi order book / market-implied probability for this specific contract. A probability estimate alone (even a well-calibrated one) is not a trade signal without a known market price to compare against. Given high expected crowding (0.85) on a thesis built from largely correlated re-measurements of the same WTI return series (effectively ~2 independent evidence lines, not 6), and zero observed mispricing evidence, the expected edge after transaction costs is unknown and plausibly at or below zero. Standing aside is the correct decision until market-price data is obtained; at that point this becomes a simple compare-and-trade decision, not a modeling exercise.
Forecasts
| Seat | Stage | P | Base | Resolves | Outcome | Brier |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Committee | final | 92% | — | 2026-11-10 | Yes | 0.007 |
| Commodities Analyst | prior | 88% | 92% | 2026-11-10 | Yes | 0.014 |
| Commodities Analyst | independent | 89% | 92% | 2026-11-10 | Yes | 0.012 |
| Commodities Analyst | revised | 89% | 92% | 2026-11-10 | Yes | 0.012 |
| Weather Analyst | prior | 95% | 94% | 2026-11-10 | Yes | 0.003 |
| Weather Analyst | independent | 94% | 94% | 2026-11-10 | Yes | 0.004 |
| Weather Analyst | revised | 94% | 94% | 2026-11-10 | Yes | 0.004 |
| Public Markets Analyst | prior | 82% | 90% | 2026-11-10 | Yes | 0.032 |
| Public Markets Analyst | independent | 90% | 90% | 2026-11-10 | Yes | 0.010 |
| Public Markets Analyst | revised | 90% | 90% | 2026-11-10 | Yes | 0.010 |
| Quantitative Researcher | prior | 78% | 89% | 2026-11-10 | Yes | 0.048 |
| Quantitative Researcher | independent | 88% | 89% | 2026-11-10 | Yes | 0.014 |
| Quantitative Researcher | revised | 88% | 89% | 2026-11-10 | Yes | 0.014 |
| Market Positioning Analyst | prior | 85% | 96% | 2026-11-10 | Yes | 0.023 |
| Market Positioning Analyst | independent | 95% | 96% | 2026-11-10 | Yes | 0.003 |
| Market Positioning Analyst | revised | 95% | 96% | 2026-11-10 | Yes | 0.003 |
| Causal Skeptic | prior | 93% | 93% | 2026-11-10 | Yes | 0.005 |
| Causal Skeptic | independent | 93% | 93% | 2026-11-10 | Yes | 0.005 |
| Causal Skeptic | revised | 93% | 93% | 2026-11-10 | Yes | 0.005 |